Foundational Category: Maintenance Planning & Strategy • ~4 min read

Maintenance Strategy Decision Tree

Select the most cost-effective maintenance strategy based on failure pattern and detectability.

Q:

How to select between CBM, Time-Based PM, RTF, or Redesign?

Based on the SAE JA1011 / Nowlan & Heap decision logic: (1) If a failure is hidden, assign a Failure Finding Task (FFT); (2) If a precursor exists with adequate P-F warning time, select Condition-Based Maintenance (CBM); (3) If age wear-out exists (β > 1.5), choose Time-Based PM; (4) If random without safety impact and low repair cost, choose Run-to-Failure (RTF); (5) If safety is compromised without viable proactive tasks, Redesign is mandatory.

RCM Decision Inputs

Toggle failure mode characteristics:

Optimal Maintenance Strategy
Condition-Based Maintenance (CBM / PdM)
Engineering Rationale: A detectable physical precursor (vibration harmonic, oil particle count, thermal delta) exists with adequate P-F warning time before functional breakdown. CBM eliminates premature replacement while preventing catastrophic secondary damage.
Recommended Interval Formulation
Inspection interval I <= (P - F interval) / 2
Governing Standard & Framework
ISO 17359 / ISO 10816 Condition Monitoring Standards
Advertisement

Systematic Maintenance Policy Selection

Research across airlines and industrial plants proved that 68% to 89% of equipment failure modes occur randomly with age. Calendar-based time-directed PMs on random equipment induce human error and infant mortality. This decision tree ensures every maintenance dollar is spent on technically feasible tasks.

Engineering & Regulatory Notice: The calculations, projections, and failure models provided in this suite are for engineering estimation and educational purposes. Verify all calculations and assumptions independently before making operational, equipment replacement, safety-critical, or regulatory compliance decisions.

Recommended Next Steps in Reliability Workflow